now justin's being named in the law suit

[flutesinger262]

give it up lady. its on tmz so i'm not gonna post it but the person suing miley claims that Justin is an adult and should have kept Miley's behavior in check.

heres what is says:

According to the amended lawsuit, Miley's parents gave Justin authority to "supervise, manage, guard, and oversee [Miley's] conduct while in [his] presence."

[joecyrusfan]

give it up lady = Yep ! but ha if she wants to keep racking up legal bills go had dig your self in the poor house !

[swe3t23]

omg ...........what are people thinking this is crazy

[apogeum]

They know Miley's parents gave him authority how?

As far as I know assumptions don't hold up in court.

[Jacksonator]

I have a hard time believing that her lawyer wouldn't have been competent enough to have included some of the adults in the photo as codefendants in the original complaint. Maybe this is their last ditch response to the judge mentioning her status as a minor as one of the many reasons he thought the case was flimsy.

[HannahMontanaMileyCyrus]

They are STILL talking about this? It's stupid. I can't believe this.

:/

[joecyrusfan]

They know Miley's parents gave him authority how?

As far as I know assumptions don't hold up in court.
That is so true 2 both
I have a hard time believing that her lawyer wouldn't have been competent enough to have included some of the adults in the photo as codefendants in the original complaint. Maybe this is their last ditch response to the judge mentioning her status as a minor as one of the many reasons he thought the case was flimsy.

Yes you think lawyer wouldn't have been competent enough to have included some of the adults in the photo as codefendants in the original complaint. = It looks he/she is not & yes case is flimsy as hell.

[jtdmiley]

Believes in me it not this bull****. Miley's the parents would not make that.

[disneymaniac]

that lady is getting my nerves!!

[Damicatz]

The initial lawsuit is baseless. Granted, I'll give the plaintiff credit for a rather, "creative" interpretation of the Unruh Act but it's baseless none the less.

I could go into a long boring legal analysis here but suffice to say, they are suing here under a California law that makes it illegal for businesses that offer services to discriminate. While Miley does have a legal business (Smiley Miley Inc) to represent her interests, the business does not exist to serve the public (merely to represent her in business matters) and her actions are not considered a public service, especially when done in private.

[Kaitlin]

They know Miley's parents gave him authority how?

As far as I know assumptions don't hold up in court.

If you are a minor and left with someone over 18 I believe they are your guardian for the time being.

[MagicMiley]

i will help you justin!! if we combine how much youre worth with how much im worth, we have aenough money to buy a plastic cup, some strings and busk outside the mall. :D

with your play and me looking ugly tramp we will get loads for guy fawkes bonfire.

SOME QUESTIONS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

whose house was they in when the pics was taken?

wasnt EVERYONE there older than her?

Where was the parents of the house?

why arent the chinese kids in the photo being sued for doing it too?

And why arent lots of Amercans suing as one chinese kid had round eyes! cheeky mofo!

and who was the F-C*** who took the photo and posted it?

[apogeum]

If you are a minor and left with someone over 18 I believe they are your guardian for the time being.
Doesn't change the fact that it's an assumption that they put Justin in charge. Even if he was, the claim that he is responsible is bogus.

[Crazium]

For the record, my name's Justin.

[rii]

If you are a minor and left with someone over 18 I believe they are your guardian for the time being.
just because you are a minor and left with an 18+ year old doesnt make them your guardian. im 17 and my older 18+ brothers and sisters - family - are not my legal guardians. im 17 and i cant even go to the dentist with my 21 year old brother alone, my mom or dad needs to be there =\ it has to be your parent or legal guardian, someone 18+ doesnt matter at all.

and im pretty sure there has to be some sort of documentation and legal shiz to make justin mileys legal guardian so unless that lady has that documentation, shes got nothing on him. in most cases, someone is appointed a legal guardian either from a will, or a court actually appoints someone. usually this spawns from parental problems and the court deems the parents unfit to take care of the child and a legal guardian is appointed. if justin was mileys legal guardian, he would basically be like a parent to miley - he is supposed to take care of miley and her property/assets. im sure the media would have jumped on this a long time ago if justin had such.

the fact that this lawsuit has gone on this far baffles me tho. everyone in their right mind knows mileys side will win this. the asian lady just wanted a quick paycheck or to damage mileys image and neither has really happened. mileys image was a lil dented from this whole thing, but it has blown over and not the whole public knows about it like her past "scandals". and the asian chick will prolly be the one losing money, im sure at the least she'll have to pay mileys legal bills for this frivolous case.

[Rockin_Miley]

are you talking about the asian look pic?

[Kaitlin]

just because you are a minor and left with an 18+ year old doesnt make them your guardian. im 17 and my older 18+ brothers and sisters - family - are not my legal guardians. im 17 and i cant even go to the dentist with my 21 year old brother alone, my mom or dad needs to be there =\ it has to be your parent or legal guardian, someone 18+ doesnt matter at all.

and im pretty sure there has to be some sort of documentation and legal shiz to make justin mileys legal guardian so unless that lady has that documentation, shes got nothing on him. in most cases, someone is appointed a legal guardian either from a will, or a court actually appoints someone. usually this spawns from parental problems and the court deems the parents unfit to take care of the child and a legal guardian is appointed. if justin was mileys legal guardian, he would basically be like a parent to miley - he is supposed to take care of miley and her property/assets. im sure the media would have jumped on this a long time ago if justin had such.

the fact that this lawsuit has gone on this far baffles me tho. everyone in their right mind knows mileys side will win this. the asian lady just wanted a quick paycheck or to damage mileys image and neither has really happened. mileys image was a lil dented from this whole thing, but it has blown over and not the whole public knows about it like her past "scandals". and the asian chick will prolly be the one losing money, im sure at the least she'll have to pay mileys legal bills for this frivolous case.


calm down. haaha.
i probably worded it wrong but if you are a minor the person left in charge of you is responsible for you.
i'm not defending that lady at all, just saying.

[rii]

calm down. haaha.
i probably worded it wrong but if you are a minor the person left in charge of you is responsible for you.
i'm not defending that lady at all, just saying.
oh wow you took my comment as hostile or something? lol. i didnt type it with a mad/hostile tone, or at least thats what i thought. the first part of my comment was the part that was directed towards you btw. the rest was just general in this topic. but yah, i still dont get the part where you say the person left in charge of a minor is responsible for the minor. if you mean as in like babysitting then yes, but as a legal guardian, no.

[Kaitlin]

oh wow you took my comment as hostile or something? lol. i didnt type it with a mad/hostile tone, or at least thats what i thought. the first part of my comment was the part that was directed towards you btw. the rest was just general in this topic. but yah, i still dont get the part where you say the person left in charge of a minor is responsible for the minor. if you mean as in like babysitting then yes, but as a legal guardian, no.

haa, no sorry i was talking about people who replied to me in general saying i was wrong... and a few other people here need to calm down a bit... :P