miley in American idol?

[gurlzrock101]

if miley tried out for american idol what do you think simon would say? do you think he would like her?

[Rachel123743]

i think he would like her i don't know why i think that becuase he hates just about evryone but i think he would like her

[RoXtar]

Hmm.......that's an interesting question. THe problem is, we'll never know because you can't be signed to a record label already if you audition for it. ;)

[mileyobsessed13]

miley would blow simon away defentily he would fall in love with her

[angel_babi]

well i dunno he didn't like kelly clarkson at the beginning
and at auditions for season one, one of the girls didn't make it because they said she sounded like a disney singer

[jg099]

well i dunno he didn't like kelly clarkson at the beginning
and at auditions for season one, one of the girls didn't make it because they said she sounded like a disney singer

What's wrong with being a disney singer? She's so good at singing! I think that Simon needs to think again!:D

[mileycyrusonly]

if miley tried out for american idol what do you think simon would say? do you think he would like her?
he wouldnt like her!I just know it.

[~!!♥Sugar Rush♥!!~]

I think that she would do really good and Simon won't say anything becuz his mouth would be on the floor!:)) :57:

[i*luv*miley*cyrus*]

i think what he means by disney singer is the people who sing in those old movies. like mickey mouse times

[miji.hannahmontana]

He wouldn't like her at all, but I do like her!

[25love25]

yeah but she cant go on

[MileyMileyMiley]

Well he wouldnt be able to say she stinks.She was number 1 seller for 2 weekes in a row.:)

[thinklikepink]

hmm i dunno honestly, its hard to tell

[conn'91]

simon cowell? no way he wouldnt like her, he would say shes good enough to go through to the next round but wouldnt be a big fan, but then again it depends what song she sings shes got that great husky voice that would really work well with a different style of music to what she sings for HM

[steph4010]

i dont know

[Sweet_sugar123]

Since Miley isn't all that great at live singing (I STILL LOVE HER!!!), I don't think simon would like her. BUT I DO!!!

[mileymontanafan]

Hmm.......that's an interesting question. THe problem is, we'll never know because you can't be signed to a record label already if you audition for it. ;)

and u have to atleast be 16...but i think simon would like her !! shes a great singer so...?

[megdolphinlover]

SIMON:*in an english accent* that was good very good good job miley
PAULA: B-E-A-UTIFUL!!!!
RANDY: man miley it was on key perfect great!!! Paula yes or no?
PAULA: absolutly yes!
RANDY: Simon yes or no?
SIMON: sure
RANDY: YES MILEY UR ON TO HOLLYWOOD!!!!

[boycrazy101]

i think that he would like her because he only lik ethe best of the best singers and thats smiley mileys(hanna) for sho sho

[flower1]

megadolphinlover, i think miley's ALREADY in Hollywood...

[hollywoodbabe_22]

for all yall ppl that r like "well she cant be on american idol cuz bla bla bla..." they're not saying that she can! they're asking wat do u think would happen if she WAS on american idol!:|

[hollywoodbabe_22]

that's not what he means by a disney singer! he means that everybody on disney channel becomes a singer. and they sound like someone that became a singer on disney channel!
i think what he means by disney singer is the people who sing in those old movies. like mickey mouse times

[flower1]

gosh, we're just wonderin!

[hollywoodbabe_22]

Well he wouldnt be able to say she stinks.She was number 1 seller for 2 weekes in a row.:)

her CD was a number 1 seller! not her! and not her voice! ppl just liked the CD!!!

[flower1]

her CD was a number 1 seller! not her! and not her voice! ppl just liked the CD!!!

FOR GOSH SAKES! CALM DON!M!

["Ifwewereamovie"]

im not sure cause he dont like people with conifidence

[hollywoodbabe_22]

FOR GOSH SAKES! CALM DON!M!
sorry i wasnt mad i just like to use exclamation points. so it kinda looks like im mad. but im not. :D ;)

[flower1]

ok...

[Kelli.Cutie101]

if miley tried out for american idol what do you think simon would say? do you think he would like her?
I think Simon would love her!! Shes such a great singer!! :57:

[vanessa*anne]

If miley tried out for american idol she would totally make it. She rocks!

[CyrusFan93]

i dont think clebrities are
allowed to join american idol

i mean the point of it is to make ppl celebrities

[hmisthebest]

i think he would cuase i hear her live and she sounds just like on the cd it was amazing

[mileycyrus/hannahmontatarulez]

She would!!
But she's sighned with Disney Records.....you can't be signed with a record label if you want to try out,and you can't sign with a record label for a year.....

[Backstroker495]

Yeah, I wish.
But she has a record label.
That means no trying out for Miley.
Too bad..........
I don't really think he would like her though seeing Simon is really tough and doesn't really like amny people's singing.