ppl might say that she singings good but listen to this...

[Froggygreen108]

ok this her really singing but she sounds weird cuz she was sick:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttzHWAjJT8Q

[mileycyrusrox454]

doesnt work

[thinklikepink]

the vieo aint there

[HannahMontana7]

it doesnt work, sorry

[goodytooshoes]

well i think she is still amazing

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ttzHWAjJT8Q

[Froggygreen108]

i know me too she was just sick all these ppl were like she stinks...

[MileyLaLa]

C'mon, give her a break. Her ear piece was to loud. Gosh.

[Froggygreen108]

omg i still luv her and thinks shes a wonderful singer!

[smiley2772]

she sounds good especially since shes singing live

[Froggygreen108]

ty for not insulting me like everyone else

[MileyLaLa]

ty for not insulting me like everyone else

I didn't mean to insult you, if you took it that way. I was talkin' about the people who posted the video on youtube saying she sucks.

[goodytooshoes]

yeah i wasn't insulting u i was just saying i liked it that day lol

truce?

[mileycyrusrox454]

she was sick and cold plus early in moring and just got of tour

[Hugs-and-Kisses]

shes a lovely singer

[MissMileyFan]

I love her. She is so amazing. And for all those people on Youtube who are saying she sux, I want to hear them sing like that! Yeah, don't think they can.

[Sweet_sugar123]

She sang ok there.... voice was a little off tune in non-chorus parts. Other than that she rocked!

[RoXtar]

IN freezing weather when you're sick, singing is hard. I congratulate her on how great she sounded in those conditions! ;)

[megdolphinlover]

geez!! her voice was like really low!! i bet sumone edited it!!!!! lol like they took out her voice and recorded theres

[Fire-Chicken]

I think she did it great. cos it not so easy when u have a cold and need to dance too.

[Nonnukka]

She does sound a little weird, but everyone gets sick.

[hanamana94]

thse people on youtube who sed she sucks suck insted -- i mean i bt if thy had their voices edited 2 sound betta thy wud neva be half as fab as miles....MILEY ROCK ON ALL THE WAY!!!!

[Froggygreen108]

ok truce sorry

[Eviie_MileyFan]

OMG people on YouTube give her a break. She is a 14 year old who sings INCREDIBLE!!!! It's freaking FREEZING that day i can TELL!!!! It is SOO not easy dance that much in the cold cause you are so cold. In my opinion that performance was outstanding considering how much she moved and how much effort she put into it. Geez, i can't sing half as good in the cold!

[MileyMileyMiley]

OMG people on YouTube give her a break. She is a 14 year old who sings INCREDIBLE!!!! It's freaking FREEZING that day i can TELL!!!! It is SOO not easy dance that much in the cold cause you are so cold. In my opinion that performance was outstanding considering how much she moved and how much effort she put into it. Geez, i can't sing half as good in the cold!

Ditto.:P

[Kaitlin]

That wasnt her best concert, but, hey, she tried!

[gopaintaroom]

not her best. but she is still good.

[Hannah Moosetana]

Hello, if you like the song...it doesn't really matter if is sounds to soft or whatever....

[mileycyrusonly]

C'mon, give her a break. Her ear piece was to loud. Gosh.
no!she was sick!

[savvinaynay]

So she had an off day, everyone does. She sounded fine, better than I would at that time of morning in the freezing cold.

[Cheerleader111]

yeah, you're right. but it says she was sick, so i wouldn't too much about it.

[iluv2write]

Ouch!!!!!!

[mileycyrusonly]

I agree with kenzie!

[jakesmyname]

I am not going to say it was one of my favorites, but everyone has an off day.

Miley isnt perfect, and neither are any of those stupid youtube posters.

They need to just give her a break.

youtube is full of haters and posers just dont listen

*off topic* kenzie marin is turning 15 not 14............i think

[miley_smiles923]

off topic

*coughiveneversaidim14cough*

[xoxglossylips]

how do you guys know she was sick? I don't really think she was sick because when she was answering those questions from that girl she sounded normal..i live reallly close to nyc and IT WAS FREEZING that day i remember! Omg. I wasn't there though but look what she has on! haha its like freezing and she's got some thin little outfit on. Also, she was singing AND dancing...which is really hard regularly let alone in COLD air! Everybody has their faults and maybe it wasn't such a great day for her. We all have those haha believe me...=]

[jmanschick]

so other times when shes singing live shes good

[jmanschick]

also i bet it was cold

[polkadot72]

well they change her voice in the studios..so I wasn't that surprised...

[niiro_tatsu]

ok give her a break!
1. she is singing and dancing at the same time
2. it is freezing cold!
3. she was ONLY 13 at the momeny
4. there is a rumor she was sick, so if thats true, try singning while you are sick.
5. its her first time singning without a backtrack

[loveEFRON]

she stunk cause she didnt lip sync

[niiro_tatsu]

she doesnt lipsing. she jsut sings with her track in the background because she has to run around and dance. you wouldnt want her to be like "If *breaths heavily* could see *breaths heavily* side of me *breaths heavily* just like...*

[flower1]

she stunk cause she didnt lip sync
C'mon! Give a break! thats not nice.

[babyblue232]

i hope that wasn't her real voice.....

[babyblue232]

well they change her voice in the studios..so I wasn't that surprised...

i know guys they change everyone's voice in the studio, even hannah montana's. now i'm not saying she totally lip-synches, but they do change her voice..

[gurlzrock101]

omg that's really bad!! but i did read n a magazine where she said she is really nervous even though it doesn't look like it but she said many fans don't know that and she said especially on good morning america! u guys should really read m magazines!! they r filled w/everything!!

[MileyCyrus7]

ha that sucks.
i hope she dosnt always sing like that.

[MileyRocksMySocks01]

guys someone made the BEST POINT EVER on there why would she sing if she was sick no stars sing when there sick. thats when lip-synicing comes to place. still idk what i belive but ill NEVER EVER EVER hate miley!!

[MileyRocksMySocks01]

they change her voice. who cares tho. shes a great actress

[Froggygreen108]

ok here is another one without her singing in the coldnesshttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mBt2ETnCNo&mode=related&search=

[loveEFRON]

if she sang with a track in the background it would sound like two people singing. okay guys i really like hannah montana but grow up. she lip syncs. i dont disrespect her for it and neither should you at least she is lip syncing to her own voice. if i was a singer and i didnt always count on myself then i would do that

[Froggygreen108]

i know but i still luv her!

[mileyobsessed13]

for me the video wont play it will play like the first 9 seconds then stop! i tried it on 3 different computers and it still wont work!

[mileyroxx]

She sounds fine.

[loveEFRON]

she just gets really tired and you can her it. thats all the video is. thats why she lip syncs. so that doesnt happen. plus it just sounds weird if she doesnt cause her voice doesnt really match the music playing in the background.

[princess of theed]

oh come on, everyone sounds really squinty when they're singing live! Miley still rocks - get over it!

[xXxTinkerxXxBellxXx]

Well its better then lypsincing cause what if you mess up on live tv infront of all your young fans.

[Miley is Smiley]

Miley Rox no matter What!**

[princess of theed]

Amen.

[kenna103]

when was that when she singed on there